Skip to Content
Blurred pink flowers with greenery.

Alternative Engagement Rings

Browse non-traditional engagement rings that speak to your unique style and personality. From gothic to vintage-inspired to western, our collection of alternative wedding rings includes a wide range of non-traditional styles to choose from.

Shop by Stone Type

"SHIMMERING SAGE" - KITE CUT MOSS AGATE ENGAGEMENT RING WITH MARQUISE MOSS AGATE ACCENTS & A DIAMOND TRACER-Staghead Designs

Moss Agate

Find Yours
Alexandrite Engagement and Wedding Rings at Staghead Designs

Alexandrite

Find Yours
Gold ring with a green gemstone on a natural background

Sapphire

Find Yours

Shop by Style

"GOLDEN" - ELK ANTLER & 14K GOLD INLAY WEDDING BAND-Staghead Designs

Nature Inspired

Find Yours
Gold ring with a pear-cut gemstone on a textured surface with a floral background

Alternative

Find Yours
Gold ring with champagne diamond center stone and diamond accents on an agate surface

Art Deco

Find Yours
Loading form…

From the Blog

Gentlmen's Gems: Men's rings with Gemstones

Gentlemen's Gems: Masculinity Has No Dress Code

Everyone deserves to wear whatever the fuck they want. That includes you, Chad! Some men have been wearing gemstones for decades because they already live by the mantra. So should we all. I wanted ...

Read More
Understanding Gemstone Certifications-Staghead Designs

Understanding Gemstone Certifications

When shopping for a gemstone, you may come across terms like certified, graded, or identified. This jargon can get confusing and we want to help you understand what it actually means. At Staghead D...

Read More
Fantasy Cut Gemstones: A Guide to One-Of-A-Kind Gemstone Cuts-Staghead Designs

Fantasy Cut Gemstones: A Guide to One-Of-A-Kind Gemstone Cuts

Many of us know the classic gemstone shapes: round, oval, pear, cushion, etc. But if you're looking for something a little less expected, adding a fantasy cut to one of these shapes can result in a...

Read More

Alternative Engagement Rings

Alternative engagement rings are made for couples who want something more personal than a traditional diamond. These wedding rings celebrate individuality through unexpected gemstones, distinctive shapes, and meaningful details. From moss agate and sapphire to salt-and-pepper diamonds, alternative engagement rings offer a wide range of colors and textures that feel organic, romantic, and one-of-a-kind. Unique shapes like marquise and oval, or vintage-inspired designs, add character while still feeling timeless.

Beyond aesthetics, alternative engagement rings often tell a deeper story. At Staghead Designs, every engagement ring is handcrafted, customizable, and designed to reflect personal values, lifestyles, or symbolism. Whether that means choosing ethically sourced stones, incorporating nature-inspired elements, or creating a fully custom design, these rings are about intention and authenticity. For couples who want their engagement ring to feel as meaningful as their love story, alternative engagement rings offer a beautiful way to break tradition and create something truly their own.

Alternative Engagement Ring FAQ

Recently Viewed